HomeKit and home automation

I am using a Sensibo A/C controller. Is not yet HomeKit compatible but does work with Siri Shortcuts for voice control.

Also have mixture of LIFX and Hue lights. Using elgato motion detectors door open /close detectors I have setup Scenes so that outside and garage lights come on for a specified time at Night when motion is detected or an outside door is opened. Also have a motion detector that turns on a light( only between midnight and 6 am) in the bathroom to 20% brightness for 2 minutes. Handy for man’s bladder syndrome

1 Like

I understand that, but once they are off they are off and on is no longer something you can control outside that switch.
Why I’d actually want a switch is when someone else walks in the room without a device (or knowledge of the voice assistant) who wants to turn on/off a light. Best of both worlds, although I do appreciate that coloured bulbs add another dimension that complicates the physical controls.

I would be more than happy to be proven wrong, but from what I understand, your standard light switches are just that a simple bridge/switch in the circuit, WiFi light switches are complete devices in their own right that also happens to allow power out to a light globe so need more wiring. Everything I’ve seen that bridges physical and remote control have this sort of setup.

If you can point me at that particular solution I’d appreciate it. I’ve asked that question on Google forums and HomeAssistant forums and been told it can’t be done. I saw some solutions of playing music TO a Google Home, but not the other way around.

To be clear, my use case is as follows:

I play music through google music.
Currently this is either through a Google Home Mini or similar.
Right now I can “Cast” to Chrome enabled devices like my Chromecast Audio or my Chrome enabled AV Receiver. This works perfectly. My understanding is that once they start playing the end devices takes over the receiving, decoding and playback of music so the initiating device isn’t technically needed anymore.

Once upon a time I used Apple Music so have a number of AirPlay capable speakers around the house.

Technically I can play Google Music on my iPhone and AirPlay it to an AirPlay speaker, but I have to manually to do this but I need to keep the phone in range since it’s actually playing the music.

What I want to do is say to my Google Home Mini “Play music in the bedroom” and have it start playing music (from google music) and cast/airplay it to the AirPlay speaker in the bedroom.

I assume I need a software/server bridge that acts like a chromecast receiver which then pipes the audio via AirPlay to an AirPlay enabled Speaker… I don’t care about lag or sync, I just want to use the speakers I have via my assistant.

I could sort of do this with an old Mac running AirServer to receive audio then Audio Hijack to redirect it to an AirPlay speaker… but even if this works I need a separate mac (or OSX VM) and maybe licence for each setup.

I’d be happy if I could get a docker container or linux based VM or something for each device.

Would Airfoil achieve this? https://rogueamoeba.com/airfoil/ edit doesn’t look like it could without using your iPhone, although I’ve never tried it

Same problem with doubletwist, I suspect. https://www.doubletwist.com/

I have 6 wifi lights from LIFX. I did not need to have any wiring changes. The lights are expensive. But, no wiring changes. They work via my router, AppleTV, and other devices. I’m pretty sure that the Philips Hue setups also dont require any rewiring. A friend of mine has been using Philips and has not made any changes. Maybe its about the light globes you chose. My light switches work just fine as they are. When the globes are in use, the switches are always “on”. They can be switched off just as easily and used only in the same way as ordinary globes (but why you’d want that after spending on wifi globes, I cant imagine)

[edit] Hmm, I may have misunderstood your previous remarks, now that I am re-reading… you want wifi light switches??? My switches are just normal ones. The Globes are self contained units.

I am disappointed with Apple’s current solution for home automation. I have only experimented with a LIFX light and an Elgato Eve pushbutton and yet I have already experienced many issues, including:

  1. The Home app is not intuitive. It is hard to discover all the functionality of the app. There are more screens than necessary in the iPad app, requiring too many clicks to achieve anything.
  2. Too many apps. The Apple Home app is not sufficient in itself to fully utilise various devices. You need to use third party apps that employ different terminology and conventions
  3. Siri needs more work. I believe that home automation via Siri must be the default mode of operation. Having to find an iPhone/iPad, login, locate and open the home app and then hit buttons, is too slow and clunky just to turn a light on and off. Voice control is simple, or it should be. Voice recognition via Siri on our Homepod is not as good as that on a Google Home Mini (which costs only 20% of the Homepod cost). It also offers far less general functionality.
  4. Difficult setup. Information on the setup process for third party devices is different depending on whether you use the third party app or the Apple Home app.
  5. Unreliable. The automation does not always work. This may be due to the Elgato Eve pushbutton. Perhaps it is a poor example device. However Apple’s home automation ecosystem should be bullet proof, because it is Apple. I like the @FaultyTaco metric, the WAF (wife approval factor). If you cannot achieve a good WAF, then the home automation project has failed. In my experience, any hint of poor reliability destroys the WAF.
  6. Conflicts. I suspect that different home automation apps conflict with each other. I could investigate further, but I do not have the time or inclination. My reasoning: it is Apple, it should just work.
  7. Slow. The automation is not as quick as I thought it would be. Sometimes the response time is very slow (4 seconds or more)
  8. Cost. The LIFX price was great. The Elgato Eve price was a rip-off.

In summary, Apple’s home automation functionality is an imperfect, expensive, technical solution. It is too complex for the average person. It is akin to using a sledgehammer to crack a nut. In addition, I suspect that most people do not have a really compelling need to crack that nut anyway.

2 Likes

I considered this option but not only would I need a sparky to come in and rewire all the switches… as all the light switches in my place are architrave mounted, I’d have to replace the architrave as well - being urethaned timber I can’t just patch it - and since I like things to match correctly and the exact moulding used isn’t readily available I’d probably have to replace all the architrave, and the matching skirting too… Before I even get past planning stage of this, the Husband Approval Factor is very low :laughing:

Ours are currently timber but need to be painted white so I can just patch, although ours are (mostly) architrave mounted too so that is a consideration.

Homepod is too rich for my blood but I find that my LIFX lights work well with Siri, and when out and about and wanting to turn lights on or off, the appleTV serves just fine as the hub and I talk to Siri on my watch or phone, whichever is handiest.

Sorry mate, misread you post. Apologies for leading you up the garden path. Have you looked into using a Raspberry Pi for creating a virtual chromecast server that is locally connected to the speaker that you want to cast to(providing the speaker has a headphone jack)?

I’ve got a virtual AirPlay server hooked up to my Bose Soundbar for Airplay handoff, I’ sure there’d be similar stuff for chromecast protocols.

1 Like

Right now I have a Chromecast audio plugged into the main mini system (which is AirPlay capable) using the line in. The downside is I have to manually turn it on and while it’s a reach my mythical server would also bridge volume controls :stuck_out_tongue:

Given the Chromecast Audio has been discontinued the Pi’s might be an idea, the bonus being they are also able to be re-purposed to do other things too… probably at the same time.

1 Like

No such thing so far, but apparently one’s being released later this year. I’m about to install a Ring doorbell, will let you know how it goes.

I’ve got Philips Hue lights, and I bought matching wireless switches, which I’ve installed above the light switches - they include a dimmer and a switch to change colours, so seems to work well - the kids love them.

Re Homebridge - I looked into it, and was thinking of running it off my Mac Mini server, but there are not that many compatible third party devices - I don’t see a point trying to put my Samsung TV on home kit for example.

1 Like

Interesting, that solves a lot of the problems I have with the technology and negates the need for an electrician and would be an excellent option for lots of places.

This thread had led me down a rabbit hole of looking into what might work for me, even more that last post which initially looked really promising. The down side to this solution though is having to replace all the bulbs with smart bulbs (both upfront and all future replacements) vs a single smart switch. This is especially an issue in a room with multiple bulbs connected to a single switch, which in my case is actually just about every room :stuck_out_tongue: which is totally a me problem. The second part (of the me problem) is the type of bulbs I’m using. I’ve got a couple of rooms which have the brightest LED lights I could buy since they are a little dark, I’m guessing the off the shelf smart bulbs generally don’t cater to the super bright end of town (although the LiFX was exceptionally bright when I had those). This includes the laundry and the kitchen with multiple LED downlights in each.

In short the solutions are going to be different for everybody, especially when we are working in a transitional time of trying to retro fit solutions into existing homes rather than designing solutions from the scratch. I still think smart switches are going to be the better long term solution for my requirements (and probably for most people), although the coloured options smart bulbs bring are interesting, it’s not something I think I would actually use in many (any??) places around my house.

That said I’m enjoying hearing about everyones different options and approaches as technology evolves.

1 Like

A couple of my LIFX are coloured… it was something I thought I would like to have and it turns out, I dont. I have nearly all my LIFX set to “Incandescent” and at about 25% except the kitchen which is at 100% brightness.

Last night I got my Ubiquiti UVC G3 cameras working in Home app via homebridge as described here. :tada:

A bit of fudging… I will write up the steps if I get around to it.

More than anything else, the biggest take away is… Home on macOS (Marzipan) is an absolutely rubbish ‘port’ of that app! :man_facepalming: Makes me worried for WWDC and 10.15!

Ok since my OP, I’ve also added the following non-Home Kit automation items that I can control remotely:

Security alarm
Sliding gate
Video doorbell
Heater/ cooler unit

These are non-Homekit since Homekit ones don’t exist yet for them.

I’m considering Blinds and Garage at the moment (no real reason, just why not). Any ideas for these?

I’m considering garage. My door and auto opener need replacing, so if I do that, I’d probably prefer homekit compatible… but does it even exist…

Ok, I found a couple of homekit Garage ones: Insignia and Ismartgate - I’m going to go with Ismargate for now, will let you know how that goes.

I also found a couple of homekit Door ones: August and Danalock - I’m going to go with August, also will let you know how that goes.

Blinds automation is a lot trickier and more expensive as there are so many of them. Ikea is going to release one later, will let you know how that goes.

1 Like

I had an August, bloody hell it munched the batteries!

Didn’t really help that I still needed a key to unlock the security door - I ended up eBaying it and going back to keys - I have one of these on the door though so at least I can wander around close to home or in the depths of the garage (where I can’t see or hear what’s going on outside) without needing keys to get back in and without being concerned that the front door is unlocked.

Excellent. I also found https://www.gogogate.com/ which might be OK for mine, since I already have an automatic opener. I can make do with it for quite a few years yet.

Chamberlain makes a bridge to add homekit to chamberlain garage door openers